This was the latest readalong book that Holly, Chachic, and I read.
The Premise: Clara Gardner is a regular seventeen year old, except for one thing – she’s part angel. With visions of a boy standing among pine trees as a fire rages towards him, Clara thinks she knows what her Purpose is. She has to save him. When her visions give her enough details to figure out where this fire is going to be, her mom uproots the whole family from Silicon Valley to Jackson Hole, Wyoming. Clara thinks all she has to do is find the boy from her vision and make sure she’s there at the right time and place to fulfill her destiny. Except things aren’t always as simple as they appear. The longer Clara is in Jackson, the more she learns how little she knows about her powers and about her vision, and how life never goes the way you expect.
My Thoughts: I have to admit that I went into this story with a little bit of trepidation. It’s not really anything against angels (although they aren’t my favorite supernatural creatures), so much as a bias against young adult paranormals these days. I think I have this little aversion to this genre because I’ve read one too many with a predictable storyline. That said, I hadn’t seen anything about Unearthly that sounded any alarms. In fact, I’d mostly read good reviews. With that in mind, and without knowing much else, I borrowed Unearthly from the library, and I’m happy to report that Unearthly doesn’t go the predictable YA paranormal route (although it does do a couple of things that seem to be common in YA these days – more on that later).
What stood out for me was a few things. First of all there’s Clara’s voice, which felt like it had the right mix of pre-adulthood maturity peppered with sarcasm and angst. She’s no airhead, but there is a balance between her angelic traits (good looks, preternatural athletic ability and angel powers), and her human ones. For all her awe-inspiring ability (wings and glowing and speaking in tongues), she is still an awkward teen. Actually, it seems like Clara is more awkward than angelic – for every moment of celestial grace, she has more than her fair share of humiliation, like a hair dye horror story and New Girl dorkiness. Then there’s Clara’s relationship with her mother. They don’t always see eye to eye, but they have a close relationship, one in which her mom is in the picture, wants to know about her life, and actually tells her daughter that she’s part angel! Basically, she’s a mom that actually acts like one.
Because of her mother, when Clara talks about her visions, she is matter-of-fact. After all, she’s known what she is since her fourteenth birthday. We don’t have to go through the slow build-up of Clara discovering her angelic side, instead the story begins a little further along. Yes, there’s a lot that Clara still doesn’t know, and her mother isn’t always forthcoming, but at least it feels like Clara has a tangible goal, one that I was curious about:
“In the beginning, there’s a boy standing in the trees. He’s around my age, in that space between child and man, maybe all of seventeen years old. I’m not sure how I know this. I can only see the back of his head, his dark hair curling damply against his neck. I feel the dry heat of the sun, so intense, drawing the life from everything. There’s a strange orange light filling the eastern sky. There’s the heavy smell of smoke. For a moment I’m filled with such a smothering grief that it’s hard to breathe. I don’t know why. I take a step toward the boy, open my mouth to call his name, only I don’t know it. The ground crunches under my feet. He hears me. He starts to turn. One more second and I will see his face.
That’s when the vision leaves me. I blink, and it’s gone.”
The fire, the boy, and Clara’s purpose drive the story. At first, everything she does is for the sole goal of getting to the place and time that the vision foretells, and at first it looks like you can see where things are going. The first day Clara arrives at school, she sees him. His name is Christian, and of course, he’s perfect. All-American, popular, and as beautiful as can be. Clara promptly faints. I cringed, expecting the usual saccharine love story to follow. In my mind, all kinds of red flags were going off. I didn’t like that Clara hardly knew Christian and was so intensely involved, vision or not. He had a girlfriend! Clara just looked like a stalker, so obsessed was she with fulfilling her purpose. But the story didn’t go the way I expected. It wasn’t about Christian so much as it was about Clara, making new friends (strange loner Angela and friendly, nice-girl Wendy), and finding a life outside of her vision. Things happen which begin to suggest that there is more to being an angel than a purpose, and there are darker things afoot that Clara’s mother never told her about. Another boy begins to get Clara’s attention. Things weren’t going like I expected and pages were flying by as I raced to find out what happened next.
The love triangle in Unearthly at first felt like a necessary evil. Clara had to discover some things about relationships for herself. I hoped that once she realized that one relationship was superficial compared to the one developed over the course of the story, that we’d see the end of it. It looked that way – the intensity of Clara’s feelings is palpable and reflected the emotions of first love. Clara seemed to know what her heart wanted, and I liked her more for it. I also really liked the romance. Then the love triangle is shoehorned back into the plot. Despite how much I want to know what happens next (enough to want to read the second book, Hallowed), and how much I liked the romance and the angel elements, the threat of the unending love triangle brought my enjoyment down a notch.
Overall: There were quite a few things I enjoyed about Unearthly. It’s a compulsively readable – I wanted to know what would happen next and the pages just few by as I got caught up in the mix of real world teen drama and paranormal intrigue, all voiced by the very human Clara. In many ways it avoids the cliches of YA paranormals – but it doesn’t completely avoid common YA tropes like the dreaded love triangle, nor is Clara always poised – I winced a few times on her behalf. I think it will depend on the reader if what Unearthly does differently from your typical paranormal YA balances out where it treads over well-worn territory. For me, the differences outweighs the commonalities, and I am curious about the second book, but if Hallowed strings the love triangle out further, I’m going to bail.
Buy: Amazon | Powell’s | The Book Depository
Bunbury in the Stacks – “Hit it!”
Mystifying Paranormal Reviews – DNF
A Room with Books – 4.5 (out of 5)
The Crooked Shelf – “completely and utterly compelling”
Literary Swoon with Cynthia Hand
Hey, you posted your review! Will work on mine so I can post it soon. I typed up a few comments after finishing the book but haven’t had a chance to get back to it. I think I didn’t enjoy reading Unearthly as much as I expected because it focused too much on the romance and not enough on the angel-bloods. I’m also curious about the second book (which I borrowed from a friend) but I heard that the love triangle is much more prominent in that.
I saw that you posted through your pingback so I will check out your review soon. I was cool with the romance, not so pleased with the love triangle. I’m sorry to hear the love triangle is more prominent in the next book! I’ll probably still get it to see for myself, but, mm, not a fan of those.
Pingback: Unearthly by Cynthia Hand | Chachic's Book Nook
I really enjoyed this book and I enjoyed the next one. Good review! I am always slow to pick up a YA book and was actually surprised with this one. Hope you like the next.
Thanks. I’m glad to hear you liked the second book too.
Great review, Janice! I know you weren’t head over heals for this one, but I think that you enjoyed what there was to enjoy from it. I appreciated where this one deviated from some tropes, though it does indeed fall victim to others. I really liked Clara’s family, and this is one of the few YA Paranormal series I still consider myself invested in.
Although you do realize that love triangles never disappear in YA series after the first book, right? D:
Love triangles never disappear? But whyyyy…? I guess I’m stubborn in my “this time it could be different!” philosophy.
I think I did enjoy what there was to enjoy – good way of putting it. I did like it more than my readalong buddies. I’m probably closer to your response to it. If that love triangle hadn’t come back, it would have fallen squarely on “Like”.
Oh thank you Janice for your review!! I’ve thought a few times about trying this – and to be honest I’m still on the fence – but your review has really helped me understand what it’s about. Y’know, reading that paragraph about Clara going to the new school and seeing Christian and fainting etc., and about how the story is largely about Clara discovering herself outside of her purpose, I started thinking, wouldn’t it be great if Clara grew to realise that Christian is just a boy she can help, but not a romantic love interest – friends maybe, but she learns that she’s more than a vision and a boy’s saviour etc.?
That’s probably a cliche as well, I know I’ve seen plenty of movies where the heroine thinks she’s in love with the incredible guy while the nerdy shy one who sticks by her has to wait till the end of the film before she realises “he’s the one!” 😉 But for YA paranormal romance, that’d still make a nice change!
(and what’s with all the perfect boys? No teenage boy is really like that, and what’s more I’m finding these hot, popular, intelligent, sporty, kind, funny, loyal etc. etc. boys to be pretty boring!)
(I finally reviewed Everneath and it had one of those too…)
“wouldn’t it be great if Clara grew to realise that Christian is just a boy she can help, but not a romantic love interest” – YES. I actually don’t know if that’s going to happen yet. To be continued in the next book I guess.
OK, true, the girl being obsessed with some guy, then falling for the guy she didn’t expect to is sort of a cliche, but to me it’s a welcome deviation from the standard triangle that gets dragged on through multiple books. I think having the resolution is a big part of wanting the heroine to come to a realization about her feelings too.
(I think I only knew one teenage boy in HS who fit the perfect boy thing, and 1) he was taken and 2) I realized even then that I didn’t know him enough to trust that he was really perfect – I just thought he showed rare signs of decency amongst a lot of immaturity).
I will check out your review of EVERNEATH!