Well, as I’ve mentioned before I’ve been eying Jane by April Lindner first because of the cover posted on Tempting Persephone, then because of Angieville’s review. There was one reviewer who didn’t find the book worked for her, but I decided to plough on and try it. The idea of a modern day retelling with Mr. Rochester as a famous rock star was too appealing to miss. (Also the cover is amazing and it called to me).
The Premise: Jane is a modern day retelling of Charlotte Brontë’s Jane Eyre. Left homeless and penniless after her parent’s accidental death, Jane Moore applies for a job as a live-in nanny, and because of her serious nature, she is considered perfect for the job as a nanny to the daughter of famous rocker, Nico Rathburn. When she gets to Thornfield Park and finally meets Nico, he isn’t the partying playboy she imagined, and she is not the easily impressed fan he’s used to dealing with. There’s a mutual fascination which turns into something more, but the secrets of Rathburn’s past threaten to ruin their fledgling relationship.
****** This review assumes you know the basic story behind Jane Eyre. If you do not, it’s probably best you just skip to the “Overall” section ******
My Thoughts: This book started off muy excellente. I felt my pulse quicken in the early pages, learning about the serious, practical Jane, desperate to find a place to live now that her semester at Sarah Lawrence is over. As she muses about her indifferent family and selfish siblings, I can’t help thinking ahead, knowing that she’s going to get the job. The anticipation was delicious, certain that she deserves something good, and but well aware that Jane has no idea what awaits her at Thornfield Park. I took to Jane very quickly. She has a level headed practicality which actually feels rather refreshing. Under circumstances where the cliched young adult heroine could be twittering and making me cringe, Jane keeps her spine up and never falters. Hooray for a nineteen year old girl who isn’t portrayed as a dimwit!
The fact that Jane didn’t compromise herself in childhood in order to please her family serves her well when she arrives at Rathburn’s estate. She’s a firm but understanding nanny to 5 year old Maddy, and when Nico Rathburn finally appears, despite an internal turbulence caused by his presence, she stays true to her steady self. Unlike other people, she doesn’t coddle the rock star, and initially she keeps herself well-contained, but Nico is intrigued by the new nanny and keeps her nearby. I knew where things were headed and so I paid careful attention. I think that at first, I liked how the two got along, but the romance may have moved a little more quickly than I would have liked. The looming disaster I knew was coming, the difference in their ages and most importantly, Nico’s role as Jane’s boss worried me more than I remember being worried by the original. I felt unsettled by them in this book, and because I knew Nico’s secret I paid more attention to how he hid it (and how he lied to do so).
I haven’t read Jane Eyre since high school, and I remember the general story, but the details are fuzzy. I remember when I first read it, I was shocked to find out about what was in the attic. After the revelation, previous hints made sense in the original book. In Jane, I already knew what was coming, so the shock value was not there, and the hints strewn throughout the book felt more heavy-handed than necessary. I wondered – did Brontë’ really leave as many hints as this? After finishing Jane, I got a copy of Jane Eyre to compare, and Jane is surprisingly true to the original, and the hints are the same. So are the lies that Mr Rochester tells his Jane about the strange things she sees in his house. I like that Jane is faithful to the original, but on the other hand, this faithfulness to Nico/Mr. Rochester’s deception left me cold.
I was dismayed when I felt out of love with where Nico and Jane’s relationship had been going. Then a surprising thing happened. I fell back in love with them. I kept reading; Jane does the right thing and leaves, and then she spends time hiding away with the St. John siblings in New Haven, Connecticut. In her time apart from Nico, Jane convinced me that her feelings weren’t just something that happened because of the thrill of having someone like Nico paying attention to her. She can go on with her life and there are other options open to her, but it’s clear that Nico has her heart, even after what he’s done. In her path to forgiving him, I guess I did too. Maybe this is a process I would have gone through re-reading Jane Eyre today. At any rate, I have a new appreciation for Jane’s withdrawal, because it makes all the difference.
Overall: This modern day retelling cleverly leaves the bones of the original intact, staying remarkably close to the plot of Jane Eyre, but in a fresh and youthful package. Jane and her rock star love are nods to Bronte’s original characters, but they are all their own. I may have been disenchanted in the middle, but the ending reversed those feelings. Ultimately, this is a book that lived up to my expectations and I closed the book with a sigh of satisfaction. Highly recommended for fans of Jane Eyre.
Buy: Amazon | Powell’s | The Book Depository
Angieville – positive
Persephone Reads – positive review
Book Fare Delights – 2 out of 5 (It didn’t work for her, but she explains why very nicely)
I’m keeping a constant eye out for this one at my local library… I’d really like to read it.
It’s quite romantic. I think you’ll like it. 🙂
Okay, adding this to my to-read list right now. I love Jane Eyre, so this should be right up my alley!
Oh, if you are a fan, yes, give it a try. Would love to see what you thought of it.
I skipped ahead to the Overall section because I haven’t read Jane Eyre. I already have a copy of Jane and I look forward to reading it after I read the original classic.
Yeah, I discuss some spoilers that people who know the original tale will know about but if you don’t know about it, it’s better when you are surprised.
I saw this book last week when I was surfing the ‘net for new & exciting reads. I’m glad to see it here in a review. Jane Eyre was a surprising favorite of mine at University so I was wary a teen renditition would fail to remain faithful, even in spirit. Your review has me rethinking that opinion! 🙂
Well, it’s hard to say how faithful fans will want a retelling to be, but I think this one is pretty faithful yet stays modern. Well, give it a try, I’d be interested to see what you thought.
I think re-tellings should take some risks and modernize or reclaim the original story. I’m not looking for something that’s extremely close to the original, but rather something that preserves the spirit and integrity of Jane Eyre while giving us something that’s entirely new. 🙂
Glad you ended up liking it! It is quite surprising how faithful it is and how well it works. I can’t wait to own a copy.
I hope they reissue it in paperback too. I would love a mass market copy.
Oh, the phantom limb quote. Love that one. I agree, it’s absolutely essential that she leaves. It’s what makes her Jane. She leaves. Even when she loves him. Even when it’s the hardest thing.
Glad you fell back in love with them. 🙂
Yes, the phantom limb. I loved reading that.
Me too. I was worried!
Oh man, I love this book so much. She struck the perfect balance with Jane and her rockstar Rochester. And that COVER!! Yes, it calls to you.
Yes, wow. I love the colors, that mist, the windswept hair! The cover wins.
Heh, it’s fun when people agree that a book is awesome.